Good morning! 

September’s wrapping up, and it’s our moment to lock in wins before the quarter closes. I’m focused on finishing strong - clear priorities, tight execution, and removing anything that slows us down. Let’s close out Q3 on the front foot.

— Lucas Robinson, Founder & CEO at BudgetMailboxes.com

🎯 This Week’s Strategy:

• Capital Improvement ROI Modeling

🌐 Boardroom Brief:

• Rising HOA Fees: New Census Data Highlights Cost Pressures
  

Strategy

🎯 Capital Improvement ROI Modeling

When it comes to managing major projects such as roof replacements, clubhouse renovations, or infrastructure upgrades many HOA boards struggle to justify costs and demonstrate value to residents. Capital Improvement ROI (Return on Investment) Modeling offers a clear, data-driven way to evaluate whether a proposed project is financially worthwhile. Instead of relying on “gut feel” or resident pressure, ROI modeling allows HOA leaders to compare expected costs with projected benefits, ensuring that every dollar spent strengthens the community’s financial and property value outlook.

How HOA Leaders Can Implement a Capital Improvement ROI Modeling Strategy

1. Identify Potential Projects

Before crunching numbers, list all possible capital improvements on the horizon. This could include repairs, replacements, or community enhancements.

Action Steps:
✅ Gather input from reserve studies, board members, and resident feedback.

✅ Rank projects based on urgency, resident impact, and long-term community goals.

✅ Separate “must-do” projects (infrastructure, safety) from “value-add” projects (aesthetic upgrades, amenities).

2. Estimate Costs and Lifespan

Accurate cost projections are the foundation of ROI modeling. Look beyond initial expenses and factor in long-term maintenance and replacement cycles.

Action Steps:
✅ Obtain at least three vendor quotes for major projects.

✅ Include both direct costs (materials, labor) and indirect costs (permits, disruption to residents).

✅ Document the expected useful life of each improvement.

3. Forecast Benefits and Value

ROI isn’t just about immediate dollars saved. Benefits can include property value increases, reduced operating costs, and higher resident satisfaction.

Action Steps:
✅ Estimate potential energy savings, insurance premium reductions, or lower repair costs from the improvement.

✅ Use real estate market data to forecast how the project may impact property values.

✅ Consider qualitative benefits, like improved resident morale or reduced complaints.

4. Calculate ROI and Payback Period

Use straightforward formulas to calculate projected ROI and the timeframe to recover costs.

Action Steps:
✅ ROI = (Total Benefits – Total Costs) ÷ Total Costs.

✅ Payback Period = Total Costs ÷ Annual Savings/Benefits.

✅ Present findings in simple charts or tables for clarity.

5. Prioritize Based on Data

Once ROI is calculated for all potential projects, boards can prioritize based on financial impact and community goals.

Action Steps:
✅ Compare ROI across projects to identify “high impact, low cost” wins.

✅ Schedule lower-priority projects for future years while focusing budget on the strongest returns.

✅ Revisit ROI models annually as costs, market conditions, and resident needs evolve.

Why It Matters

Capital Improvement ROI Modeling empowers HOA leaders to make smarter, more defensible decisions. By grounding project approvals in data, boards reduce the risk of overspending, increase transparency with residents, and align investments with long-term community value. In an era where homeowners expect both fiscal responsibility and visible improvements, ROI modeling is the bridge between financial stewardship and community enhancement.

Join All-in on AI:
The Community for Next-Gen Operators

Boardroom Brief

Rising HOA Fees: New Census Data Highlights Cost Pressures

A new report from the U.S. Census Bureau shows that HOA and condo association fees are placing an increasingly heavy burden on homeowners nationwide. New York topped the list in 2024, with residents paying a median of $739 per month, far above the national median of $135. The District of Columbia ($505) and Hawaii ($470) followed, while Arkansas reported the lowest median at just $47. In total, 21.6 million of America’s 86.6 million owner-occupied households paid HOA or condo fees last year. According to Census Bureau economist Jacob Fabina, these costs consumed over 21% of income for mortgage-holding households, straining affordability in already tight housing markets. For HOA boards and community leaders, the findings underscore the importance of transparent financial management, reserve planning, and clear communication about how fees are allocated. Rising assessments are not just numbers, they directly affect resident trust, property marketability, and the financial resilience of communities.

Game

🎉 Fun Finale: Play & Poll